Bundling policies for discounts

38 steps across 11 sections

1. Discount Ranges

  • General range 5-25% off one or both policies
  • Average savings Approximately $500-$870/year when bundling home + auto
  • Most common discount 10-20%

2. Home + Auto (Most Common)

  • Most widely available bundle
  • Largest savings in absolute dollars
  • Nearly every major insurer offers this combination
  • Average savings: $500-$870/year

3. Renters + Auto

  • Great for people who don't own a home
  • Renters insurance is already cheap ($15-$30/month), so the percentage discount may not amount to much in dollars
  • Still worth doing since it costs nothing extra and simplifies billing

4. Home + Auto + Umbrella

  • Adding umbrella liability to an existing bundle often triggers additional discounts
  • Umbrella policies are relatively cheap ($300-$600/year for $1M coverage)
  • The multi-policy discount can offset most or all of the umbrella premium cost
  • Provides significantly more liability protection

5. Other Bundleable Policies

  • Life insurance + home/auto
  • Motorcycle/RV/boat + auto
  • Landlord/rental property + personal home + auto
  • Business insurance + personal lines (some carriers)

6. Scenario 1: One Insurer Has a Much Better Standalone Rate

  • Example: Nationwide auto at $1,200/year + Progressive home at $1,500/year = $2,700 total
  • vs. Progressive bundle at $3,224/year with 15% discount = $2,740
  • The "bundle" costs MORE than separate best-rate policies
  • Always compare Total cost of bundle vs. total cost of separate best-in-class policies

7. Scenario 2: Service Quality Suffers

  • Companies specializing in one type of insurance (e.g., auto-only) sometimes offer better service and lower prices than multi-line carriers
  • Consumer satisfaction surveys show bundled customers are sometimes LESS satisfied than those with separate policies
  • If your auto insurer is excellent but their homeowners coverage gets poor reviews, bundling may not be wise

8. Scenario 3: You're Locked into a Bad Deal

  • Bundling creates switching costs — leaving one policy means losing the discount on the other
  • This can keep you with an insurer even when rates increase
  • Insurers know this and may raise rates over time, counting on inertia

9. Scenario 4: Your Renters Insurance Is Too Cheap to Matter

  • If renters insurance costs $20/month and bundling saves 10%, you save $24/year
  • Not worth compromising on auto insurance quality for $24

10. Scenario 5: Niche Needs

  • If you need specialized coverage (flood, earthquake, classic car, high-value home), the specialist insurer may be far superior
  • Bundling with a generalist insurer to get a discount on auto may leave you underinsured on the specialty coverage

11. Step-by-Step

  • Get standalone quotes: Get the best auto quote and best home/renters quote separately from different companies
  • Get bundle quotes: Get 3+ bundled quotes from companies that offer both
  • Compare total cost: Add up the standalone bests vs. the bundled total — which is cheaper?
  • Check coverage quality: Ensure the bundle doesn't sacrifice coverage limits, deductibles, or endorsements
  • Read reviews: Check claims satisfaction for each type of coverage at the bundling company
  • Re-evaluate annually: Rates change; what was the best deal last year may not be this year

Sources

Related Checklists