Online degree evaluation

Online degrees have become mainstream, with over 40% of college students taking at least one online course. However, the quality of online programs varies enormously — from elite universities offering rigorous online degrees identical to their on-campus programs, to outright diploma mills that sell worthless credentials.

59 steps across 12 sections

1. Institutional Accreditation (formerly "Regional" vs. "National")

  • Higher Learning Commission (HLC)
  • Southern Association of Colleges and Schools Commission on Colleges (SACSCOC)
  • Middle States Commission on Higher Education (MSCHE)
  • New England Commission of Higher Education (NECHE)
  • Northwest Commission on Colleges and Universities (NWCCU)
  • WASC Senior College and University Commission (WSCUC)
  • Most traditional universities and respected online programs hold this type of accreditation
  • Credits transfer most easily between these institutions
  • Graduate schools overwhelmingly prefer or require degrees from these institutions
  • Employers who check accreditation look for these

2. Programmatic Accreditation

  • Business: AACSB, ACBSP, or IACBE
  • Nursing: CCNE or ACEN
  • Education: CAEP
  • Engineering: ABET
  • Social Work: CSWE
  • Counseling: CACREP

3. How to Verify Accreditation

  • U.S. Department of Education Database (DAPIP): ope.ed.gov/dapip — search for any school
  • CHEA Directory: chea.org/search-institutions — Council for Higher Education Accreditation
  • The school's own website: Accredited schools display their accreditation prominently; look for the accreditor's name and verify independently
  • Never take the school's word alone — always verify through DAPIP or CHEA

4. Academic Rigor

  • Faculty credentials: Are professors holding terminal degrees (PhD, EdD, etc.) in their field? Are they full-time faculty or all adjuncts?
  • Course structure: Are courses structured with clear learning objectives, regular assignments, and meaningful assessments? Or are they self-paced with minimal interaction?
  • Student-to-faculty ratio: Lower is better for meaningful interaction; 20:1 or less is good
  • Academic integrity measures: Does the program use proctored exams, plagiarism detection, and other safeguards?
  • Curriculum alignment: Is the curriculum aligned with professional standards and industry expectations?

5. Student Support Services

  • Academic advising: Do you have access to a dedicated advisor?
  • Career services: Does the school offer career counseling, resume help, and job placement assistance to online students?
  • Tutoring and writing centers: Available online, not just on campus?
  • Library access: Full digital library access, including databases and research journals?
  • Technical support: 24/7 or at least extended-hours IT help desk?
  • Disability services: Accessible to online students?

6. Outcomes Data

  • Graduation rate: What percentage of students who start the program complete it? (Below 30% is a red flag)
  • Job placement rate: What percentage of graduates are employed in their field within 6-12 months?
  • Average salary after graduation: Compare to national averages for the field
  • Student loan default rate: High default rates suggest graduates are not earning enough to repay loans
  • Where to find this data: College Scorecard (collegescorecard.ed.gov), school's own outcomes page, NCES IPEDS data

7. Learning Platform and Technology

  • Learning Management System (LMS): Major platforms (Canvas, Blackboard, D2L Brightspace, Moodle) are standard; a custom or obscure LMS may indicate a less established program
  • Mobile accessibility: Can you access courses on mobile devices?
  • Synchronous vs. asynchronous: Does the program require real-time attendance (synchronous) or offer flexibility (asynchronous)? What mix works for your schedule?
  • Technical requirements: What hardware, software, and internet speed are needed? Can your current setup handle it?

8. Current State (2026)

  • Employer acceptance has increased dramatically since 2020; the pandemic normalized online learning
  • The school's reputation matters more than the delivery format. An online degree from Arizona State, Penn State, or the University of Florida carries the same weight as their on-campus degrees
  • Some fields are more accepting than others: IT, business, education, and healthcare administration readily accept online degrees; fields requiring hands-on training (engineering, lab sciences) may be more skeptical
  • Most employers cannot distinguish online vs. on-campus degrees — many universities issue identical diplomas regardless of modality

9. When Online Degrees Face Scrutiny

  • Unaccredited or nationally-only accredited programs
  • For-profit schools with poor reputations (some hiring managers automatically filter these)
  • Fields requiring extensive in-person collaboration, lab work, or clinical training
  • Very senior or prestigious positions where institutional prestige is heavily weighted

10. How to Maximize Your Online Degree's Value

  • Choose a well-known, institutionally accredited university
  • If possible, choose a program where the degree does not indicate "online" on the transcript or diploma
  • Build your professional network through internships, professional associations, and industry events
  • Supplement with relevant certifications and practical experience
  • Highlight projects, capstones, and achievements rather than just the degree name

11. Asynchronous (Most Flexible)

  • Complete coursework on your own schedule within weekly deadlines
  • No required real-time class meetings
  • Best for: Working professionals, parents, people in different time zones

12. Synchronous (Structured)

  • Required real-time virtual class meetings at set times
  • More interaction with faculty and peers
  • Best for: Students who benefit from structure and accountability

Common Mistakes

  • Not verifying accreditation independently
  • Choosing based on lowest cost alone
  • Ignoring employer perception in your specific field
  • Assuming all online degrees are equal
  • Not checking credit transfer policies

Pro Tips

  • Use the College Scorecard
  • Check if the diploma distinguishes "online."
  • Look for schools with strong alumni networks
  • Take one course before committing full-time
  • Verify that the program qualifies for employer tuition reimbursement

Sources

Related Checklists